Did Jephthah Sacrifice His Daughter—Yes or No?

by Feb 13, 2016Personal, Theology2 comments

A post of mine at the Logos Talk Blog regarding Jephthah has generated a great deal of interesting discussion from readers. I’m getting a little cross-section of evangelical hermeneutics in action.

I urge my personal blog readers to go and take the vote in the middle of the post!

Screen Shot 2016-02-13 at 1.49.06 PM

Read More 

Review: The Power Broker, by Robert Caro

Review: The Power Broker, by Robert Caro

The Power Broker: Robert Moses and the Fall of New York by Robert A. Caro My rating: 5 of 5 stars Robert Caro is fascinated by power. He has given his life to exploring how it is gained and kept. And in Robert Moses, the subject of this epic book, power looks like the...

Review: Finding the Right Hills to Die On by Gavin Ortlund

Review: Finding the Right Hills to Die On by Gavin Ortlund

Finding the Right Hills to Die On: The Case for Theological Triage by Gavin Ortlund My rating: 4 of 5 stars Gracious, clear, accessible. Extremely well done. I nearly docked him a star for being ever-so-slightly in a different place than I am on creationism (though I...

Leave a comment.

  1. bethyada

    Good response from your readers!

    I have heard both positions. In terms of the book we go from Othniel, son-in-law of Caleb the righteous spy, to Samson, the womaniser. Jephthah is pretty late in the piece. So he certainly could have offered his daughter as a human sacrifice—wrong as that would be. I probably would have gone with that answer previously. But there are some parts to the story that seem a little unusual if his daughter was killed. Why say Jephthah did as he vowed rather than say Jephthah offered up his daughter as a burnt offering? And why would she mourn her virginity? While she would die a virgin (if she was killed), it seems more likely she would mourn something that was a fate for the rest of her full life.

    Further, Jephthah rebukes the Ammonites with a history of the occupation of the disputed territory since Joshua 300 years previous, suggesting he was very knowledgeable. Why would Jephthah not also be knowledgeable about the Law? If so then he would know that persons devoted to God were to be exchanged for an animal. Only men who were devoted to destruction (ie. men who come under God’s judgment) were not to be spared. Jephthah’s daughter doesn’t meet that criterion.

    So why I can accept that Jephthah wrongly put his daughter to death—men doing God’s work sin (David, Peter, Abraham, the Prophet who ate in Samaria)—I am not so certain he did. He could exchange his daughter for a clean animal and she would have been devoted to God in the temple a virgin.

  2. bethyada

    Just to be clear, I am not certain. I sway toward my current position, but I note the objections. And if there is one refrain throughout the book it is men did what was right in their own eyes.

    And without disparaging Jephthah’s daughter, the temple maidservants weren’t always virgins, at least not during Eli’s judgeship.


Leave a Reply